Home / Comparisons

Luggage comparisons

Updated 2026-09-24. Researched from airline pages and published specifications.

Quick answerThe comparison most people need is hard shell vs soft shell: hardside cases resist crushing and rain, softside cases are usually lighter and have front pockets and expansion that make a carry-on easier to live with.

Carry-ons that meet American's limit (22 x 14 x 9 in)

Limit per American's published policy; several other US airlines publish the same box. Check your airline before you fly. Pick another airline.

Hardside and softside carry-ons

Baggage claim carousels in an airport arrivals hall
Photo: Mark Stuckey on Unsplash